Bion Environmental Technologies, Inc. (OTCQX: BNET)
Bion Environmental Technologies Inc. (OTCQB: BNET)
provides waste stream remediation for animal operations, primarily
for large dairy, beef cattle and hog farms. To reduce pollution
caused by animal waste, BNET uses its patented technology which
relies on a combination of mechanical processes and
naturally-occurring microbes to treat the waste before disposal. The
treatment substantially reduces runoff of excess nutrients, nitrogen
and phosphorus, as well as pathogens and antibiotics, and ammonia
and greenhouse gas emissions. Livestock waste has been recently
acknowledged by the United Nations (and others) as one of the
greatest environmental problems we have in the world today.
Using BNET’s patented processes, the livestock ‘waste’ nutrients are
stabilized and captured to produce organic soil and fertilizer
products and cellulosic biomass is collected for production of
renewable energy. The company is working closely with federal and
state agencies in Pennsylvania to address the major problem of
animal waste run-off from farms into the Chesapeake Bay and other
U.S. waters. BNET has provided solutions to the livestock industry
since 1990, its next generation technology is the result of $65
million and more than 20 years of R&D.
In our opinion, BNET is a company whose time has come. With the
growing understanding of the serious environmental impacts from
livestock waste, Bion is now uniquely positioned to monetize its
technology and expertise. We also believe investors who buy the
stock here have the potential to make multiples on their money.
BNET has the potential to generate millions of dollars in revenue
from the sale of nutrient credits from its most recent project,
alone, which we anticipate to be the first of many more. Not only
will investors benefit, but the environment will benefit as well,
since nitrogen runoff from animal waste will be reduced and that
runoff is now being viewed by the US EPA as one of the most
difficult environmental problems we face in the 21st
century.
The opportunity for BNET is so compelling that just last year Ed
Schafer, former Governor of North Dakota and former Secretary of the
U.S. Department of Agriculture, joined BNET’s management team and
became its Executive Vice Chairman. Mr. Schafer was the U.S.
Secretary of Agriculture from 2008 to 2009 and Governor of North
Dakota from 1992 to 2000. In addition to his public sector
experience, he has successfully led a multi-national consumer
products business and several entrepreneurial start-up companies. It
is our opinion that men of Mr. Schafer’s caliber generally do not
devote their time and risk their reputation on a commercial
enterprise unless it has a tremendous chance of success. You can see
from BNET’s SEC filings that Mr. Schafer is so convinced of BNET’s
success, he plans to make the bulk of his compensation by exercising
stock options at much higher prices.
In our opinion, the near term pay on BNET is going to come from the
nutrient credit trading program, which is based on federally EPA
mandated reductions of nitrogen and phosphorus flowing into the
Chesapeake Bay from sewage treatment plants and other sources. This
program gives municipalities the option of buying credits from
farmers rather than spending millions to upgrade their facilities to
meet the mandate. The idea behind this is that the farmer can
provide nitrogen reductions at their source that will benefit the
environment equally, but at a far lower cost than the downstream
municipality that has to process substantially more water in order
to remove the now-diluted nitrogen.
The best explanation is to describe the Company’s new project:
Bion just held the Grand Opening of its showcase project at Kreider
Farms in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (in the Chesapeake Bay
Watershed). Not only will the system have a substantial positive
impact on the Chesapeake Bay, as well as local waters, it will be a
model to help establish and define policies and strategies that will
be used to deal with livestock waste pollution in the Bay, and
ultimately, the Mississippi River Basin, the Central Valley in
California, and many other locations in the U.S.
Kreider Farms
Kreider Farms is a 3,500 acre dairy farm near Manheim, Pa. with
around 2,000 cows. It is also home to BNET's $7.5 million
installation that reduces nutrients and other pollutants that now
find their way into the area’s streams and watersheds, provides
nutrient credit offsets and will generate renewable energy to power
up to 2,700 homes from the Phase 2 renewable energy project
utilizing Kreider’s dairy and poultry waste streams.
The initial Kreider project was funded with a low-interest $7.5
million loan from the Pennsylvania Infrastructure Investment
Authority (PENNVEST). PENNVEST is the state agency tasked with
financing water infrastructure projects for the Pennsylvania.
PENNVEST is a big proponent of developing and enhancing the State’s
existing nutrient credit trading program to allow it to provide
cost-effective solutions to Pennsylvania’s obligations to reduce
nitrogen to the Chesapeake Bay.
In our opinion, the key to success at Kreider Farms and
future Bion systems is BNET’s unique ability to provide low cost
treatment and removal of livestock waste nutrients on-site at their
source, rather than substantially more expensive treatment
downstream.
BNET’s system at Kreider Farms will reduce nitrogen and phosphorus
runoff, thereby generating verified long-term nitrogen and
phosphorus credits that Pennsylvania, and ultimately we believe,
other Chesapeake Bay states, can use to offset their obligations to
reduce nitrogen to the Bay and avoid expensive infrastructure
projects. The BNET system at Kreider Farms is initially treating the
waste from the dairy farm’s 1,200-cow active milking herd only and
will generate approximately 140,000 nitrogen credits annually that
can be used to offset Pennsylvania’s nitrogen reduction requirements
under the Chesapeake Bay Tributary Strategy. The rest of the herd
will be added to Phase 1 at a later date; but BNET is already
working on Phase 2 of the project that will treat the waste from
five million chickens from Kreider’s poultry operations. They
expect the final numbers from the Kreider operations and a couple
other poultry facilities in the vicinity will be somewhere around
three million credits by the end of 2012 and they clearly expect to
receive $8 to $10 per credit annually.
As previously mentioned, these nutrient credits can be used by
municipal wastewater and regional storm water facilities as
qualified offsets for the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's
(EPA) Chesapeake Bay initiative. It is anticipated that
municipalities in other states in the Chesapeake Bay watershed area
will also be able to purchase credits produced in Pennsylvania from
BNET.
The downstream treatment alternative: In the Chesapeake Bay
basin, average nitrogen and phosphorous remediation costs (including
both municipal treatment and storm water facilities) exceeds $40 per
pound of nitrogen removed annually when operating and capital costs
are included (many municipalities face much higher removal costs).
Based on the generation of credits (at $10 per pound), the
BNET-Kreider Project and others could save Pennsylvania
taxpayers approximately $30 million annually per million pounds of
nitrogen reduced. If used primarily to offset storm
water treatment inventories, the savings could be substantially
higher. Pennsylvania’s livestock industry has the potential to
produce reductions in excess of the 25 million pounds of nitrogen
projected in the PA DEP Watershed Implementation Plan, with the
result being the ability to export cost effective nitrogen and
phosphorous reduction credits to adjoining Chesapeake Bay basin
states.
By the way, there is a very interesting video available from BNET’s
homepage (look for New Video in red
www.biontech.com) from the Grand Opening. We have posted a link
t=in the right column. It has part of the Harrisburg TV coverage and
then quotes from representatives of some of the biggest stakeholders
in the Chesapeake Bay: PA Secretary of Agriculture, Secretary of
Department of Enviro Protection, Exec Director of PENNVEST.
The benefit for BNET shareholders is that a significant amount of
revenue can be generated from the sale of these credits. BNET has
publicly stated it is now verifying the initial credits on its
project at Kreider Farms; Bion anticipates that it will ultimately
produce around 3 million credits from Kreider projects alone. The
program has seen only a handful of trades since it began six years
ago, but current EPA mandates are pushing municipalities to clean
up, purchase credits, or face stiff fines; reductions have to begin
in 2012. In our opinion, this is the catalyst that has been
necessary to move BNET to the next level. In an 8-k filing last
year, BNET disclosed it expected to sell these credits for $8 to $10
per pound and still make a profit.
New investors have the advantage of coming into BNET after almost
two decades of R&D that has led to a proven solution with good IP
coverage, and at a price that is less than the technology cost. In
our opinion, now that BNET is transitioning from R&D to commercial
operations and should begin generating revenue soon, this could be
the most opportune time to buy the stock. And the last chance to
buy it at these low levels. At this time, BNET’s market
capitalization is still less than the accumulated investment in the
technology. But BNET is right in the middle of verifying its
initial credits, as well certifying its Phase 2 credits; once these
are accomplished, things could happen quickly. With an initial
inventory of credits, BNET can begin selling them. With the
certification of Phase 2, BNET can begin the permitting and
construction that leads to higher revenues in mid-2012 with the
eventual sale of those credits. Much like a pharmaceutical company
with a long period of R&D, then after final approvals a quick ramp
up in revenue, we think that BNET stock could spike higher in price
and move very rapidly. The icing on the cake is that BNET is years
ahead of the competition in both its technology and relationships
with environmental and agricultural agencies.
Scope of Opportunity and Profit Potential
BNET anticipates that the Kreider System and Kreider Renewable
Energy Facility, as well as future projects, will generate revenue
from the sale of nutrient Credits, renewable energy (and related
credits), nutrient sales (fertilizer/feed products) and potentially
credits for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and phosphorus
to the local watershed.
BNET estimates that the overall market opportunity for credits in
the Chesapeake Bay watershed is large and of long duration. Most (if
not all) of the publicly proposed new (or upgraded) municipal waste
water and storm water treatment facilities in the Chesapeake Bay
watershed in Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and Washington, DC
have projected costs (capital and operating) far in excess of the
costs involved in reducing nutrients using BNET’s Systems to treat
CAFO wastes at the source. While regulatory and enforcement policy
is still evolving and, therefore, the impact of those future
policies upon BNET's operations cannot be precisely predicted and/or
fully quantified, BNET believes that the tremendous difference
between its cost to remove nutrients from a concentrated livestock
manure waste stream and the cost required for reduction of nutrients
from diluted conventional waste water and storm water treatment
technologies makes it reasonable to believe that BNET's potential
profitability from projects in the Chesapeake Bay watershed should
be significant.
Based on the aggregate size of livestock operations in the
Chesapeake Bay watershed, BNET believes that the potential market
for reductions in nitrogen loadings to the Chesapeake Bay watershed
from livestock can be reasonably anticipated to increase tenfold (or
more) to total in excess of 65 million (or more) pounds annually
(including airborne ammonia) over the next decade with certified
tradable nutrient credits potentially generated equaling 50% to 60%
of that aggregate required nitrogen reduction. BNET hopes that some
significant portion of the nutrient reductions related to this
clean-up mandate will be made by BNET Systems (which portion cannot
be reasonably estimated at this time).
How Bad is the Livestock Waste Problem?
The impact of livestock waste has been identified by the U.N. as one
of the greatest environmental threats facing the world today. U.S.
livestock produce more than 1.4 billion tons of organic waste that
is essentially untreated. Much of the waste is now produced on large
scale farms or CAFOs. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency, there are more than 20,000 CAFOs in the U.S. alone. The
current method of disposal of animal waste on these CAFOs is to
temporarily store it in ‘lagoons’ or in piles on the ground and
spray it on fields as fertilizer. The problem is that spraying
animal waste on fields can overwhelm the surrounding watershed’s
natural ability to cope with it. Excess nutrients – nitrogen and
phosphorus – are in a water-soluble form that often runs-off to
contaminate downstream waters and significant amounts of ammonia,
greenhouse and other harmful gases volatilize from the waste.
Ammonia from the manure moves downwind where it re-deposits, adding
significantly more nitrogen back into the watershed. There is no way
to paint a pretty picture of this process, however, you should start
to see the need for a better solution, like the one BNET provides.
Runoff of excess nitrogen from agricultural activities, municipal
waste treatment plants and an assortment of urban/suburban
activities cause algal blooms in downstream coastal waters. When the
runoff and the nitrogen it supplies subsides, the algae dies,
leading to hypoxic zones where dissolved oxygen levels fall below
levels necessary to sustain most animal life, such as the ‘Dead
Zone’ at the mouth of the Mississippi River in the Gulf of Mexico.
According to a recent task group made up of U.S. EPA staff and state
regulators, “nitrogen and phosphorus pollution has the potential to
become one of the costliest, most difficult environmental problems
we face in the 21st century.” Livestock waste has been identified as
one of the primary contributors of excess nitrogen to the Chesapeake
Bay, Gulf of Mexico, and many other water basins.
To date, efforts to control excess nutrients have largely relied on
expensive downstream treatment provided by municipal wastewater
plants and storm water treatment of nutrients that have already
entered the water supply. Higher cost treatment from these
facilities results from them having to remove nutrients that have
been diluted, requiring the processing of significantly greater
volumes of water to capture the nutrients. To comply with the need
to make further nutrient reductions to protect our waterways, EPA
has pushed for additional upgrades to these wastewater plants and
the development of new storm water treatment infrastructure – both
are very expensive alternatives.
BNET’s unique technology treats the waste at a much lower cost by
capturing and stabilizing the nitrogen on-site at its source, before
it has a chance to disperse into the watershed. When considering the
Chesapeake Bay, as well as the Gulf of Mexico, Great Lakes and other
waters, this more cost-effective strategy could result in a
potential savings to taxpayers of billions of dollars annually. The
‘treat locally’ strategy also provides benefits to the local
community and environment that include reduction of nitrogen to
underground aquifers and local waterways.
We realize that some investors may hold their nose and make a funny
face when they read how BNET makes money. But now that the
perception has become reality, BNET is an eco-friendly,
environmental services company whose time has come. The large-scale,
industrial type farms are here to stay. A system made up of family
farms with free-range chickens and beef A) simply cannot produce
enough protein to sustain our current population, much less the
several billion more expected by 2025, and B) would result in a
substantially greater environmental problem than we face today. The
key is to produce this protein in the most environmentally AND
economically sustainable manner possible. BNET’s unique technology
provides that bridge between economic efficiency and environmental
sustainability that has been lacking.
Summary
The State of Pennsylvania has taken the lead by recognizing that
airborne livestock nitrogen is a significant contributor to
destroying the environment, and for enabling technology providers,
such as BNET, to receive credits for those reductions based upon
approved nutrient reduction verification plans.
According to the EPA, excess nitrogen loadings in the Mississippi
River basin are estimated to be more than ten times that of the
Chesapeake Bay. Livestock waste is a major source of nutrients in
the Mississippi River Basin, as well.
In our opinion, and that of BNET management, the strategies
developed in the Chesapeake Bay Program can be duplicated and
utilized to deal with the much larger nutrient pollution problems of
the Mississippi River Basin that are a primary cause of the 'Dead
Zone' in the Gulf of Mexico and similar problems in the Great Lakes
and elsewhere. The US EPA has stated the intention that the
strategies being developed for the Chesapeake Bay will be utilized
in the Mississippi River Basin and other watersheds in the U.S. The
Mississippi River Basin alone has been estimated to require more
than 1 billion pounds of annual nitrogen reduction to remediate the
‘dead zone’ in the Gulf of Mexico.
Applying the same metrics as above (BNET’s ability to profitably
provide nitrogen reductions at a cost of $8-10 per pound per year
compared to municipal wastewater and storm water removal costs of
$40 or higher per pound per year), using BNET-type solutions would
represent a potential benefit in excess of $30 billion annually to
tax- and rate-payers of the 31 Mississippi River Basin states and
the federal government.
It is difficult to quantify with any kind of accuracy just how big
the opportunity in front of BNET really is; after all, it is truly
an ‘emerging market’ of its own. But, in our opinion, BNET could go
from being a small company to a large company in a matter of months
as large business opportunities for utilization of its technology as
efforts to clean up such polluted areas develop. As many of you
know, the stock market always trades on anticipated results. In our
opinion, as BNET sells its first long-term nitrogen and phosphorus
credits, the stock is going to be hitting the radar screens of some
of the larger players..
OTC
Symbol: BNET
Current Price: $2.74
Shares Outstanding: 15.73 million
Market Cap: $43.11 million
52 Week Range:
52-Week Low: $1.30
52-Week High: $3.66
Corporate Offices:
Box 566 / 1774 Summitview Way
Crestone, CO 81131
Here are a few of the
accolades BNET has received in recent months.
Media Coverage

Dairy cows at Kreider Farms have a lot to offer the
demonstration project that aims to turn waste into safe fertilizer
and renewable energy. (DAVID SWANSON / Philadelphia Enquirer Staff
Photographer)

| Once funneled through a
machine that separates out cellulose, waste turns mulchlike
and could someday be used as fuel. (DAVID SWANSON /
Philadelphia Enquirer Staff Photographer) |